Treatise on the Emendation of the Intellect · §17 · Reflections on §§1–17
Episode 6
What place do pleasure and money have in a good life? Michah and Clare explore Spinoza’s practical advice about pleasure, money and living among others. How can we enjoy life and fit into our communities without losing sight of what matters most? Bringing this first series to a close, they reflect on the personal story Spinoza has told us, what it reveals about his pursuit of joy, and the different starting point that awaits us in the Ethics.
Editorial preview These show notes are drafts for review.
§17, revisiting §4 · Making room for pleasure
After his earlier warnings about sensual pleasure, Spinoza now gives enjoyment a place in the philosophical life. Michah and Clare explore his advice to enjoy pleasures insofar as they safeguard our health, considering both mind and body. The question becomes how to enjoy what sustains us without becoming dependent on it, and why freedom matters to the distinction between pleasure and compulsion.
§17 · Money and belonging
Spinoza advises us to seek enough money to sustain life and health, and to follow the customs of our community where they do not conflict with our aim. Michah and Clare discuss how social standing can help others give our ideas a favourable hearing. From Muhammad Ali’s cars to Spinoza’s scruffy clothes, the conversation explores the practical importance of appearances and the limits of fitting in.
§17 · Returning to ordinary life
The three rules of living return to the conventional goods Spinoza questioned at the beginning: honour, pleasure and wealth. Michah and Clare consider how these pursuits can support a philosophical life when kept in their proper place. Spinoza’s advice offers a way to live among others while pursuing a different understanding of what makes life good, allowing some compromise without losing sight of what matters most.
Looking ahead · A different way into philosophy
As their reading of the opening paragraphs ends, Michah and Clare look ahead to the Ethics. The Treatise begins with fear, sadness and the desire for joy; the Ethics begins with God and the fundamental structure of reality. They consider what makes the earlier text such an accessible introduction to Spinoza, and why he might have turned to a different form for his major work.
Looking back · How personal should philosophy be?
Spinoza’s account of his own experience invites readers to recognise something of their lives in his. Yet making philosophy too personal risks turning attention towards the philosopher himself. Michah and Clare explore this tension, asking how Spinoza can inspire readers without becoming the centre of their attention, and how the absence of specific names, dates and events leaves space for our own experiences.
Looking back · A story that leads towards joy
Is Spinoza describing his life, shaping a literary narrative, or doing both? With comparisons to Descartes’s Meditations and Augustine’s Confessions, Michah and Clare reflect on how personal experience can become a vehicle for philosophical thought. The series closes by returning to the desire for joy that set the whole inquiry in motion, preparing the way for a new series reading the Ethics.
Read alongside us
The edition used in the podcast
A Spinoza Reader
The Ethics and Other Works · Edited and translated by Edwin Curley
The hosts read from this Princeton University Press anthology. It includes the Ethics and selections from Spinoza’s other writings. Follow the paragraph numbers listed with each episode; page numbers vary between editions.
Exclusive podcast offer: buy A Spinoza Reader, edited by Edwin Curley, direct from Princeton University Press and use code SPINOZA (all caps) for 40% off.
