Treatise on the Emendation of the Intellect · §§14–17
Episode 5
How can philosophy change the world? Michah and Clare explore Spinoza’s plans for a society that helps more people flourish. Scientific knowledge, education, health and technology all have a part to play, but first we need to heal the intellect. The discussion leads to his first practical rule of living: speak in ways that ordinary people can understand. What does this tell us about how to read Spinoza himself?
Editorial preview These show notes are drafts for review.
§14 · A good to pursue together
Spinoza’s search for happiness becomes a project of collective transformation. He wants others to share both his understanding and his desire for a different way of living. Michah and Clare explore the scale of this ambition: if fear, anxiety and the pursuit of passing pleasures are deeply ingrained in our culture, changing ourselves also raises questions about changing the society we live in.
§14 · What is knowledge for?
Spinoza calls for as much knowledge of nature as we need to attain the highest good. Michah and Clare consider why truth is essential to his philosophical path, while asking what distinguishes research directed towards human flourishing from research pursued for wealth, honour or pleasure. His commitment to understanding nature also brings freedom of thought into view: inquiry must be able to proceed without religious restrictions.
§§14–15 · A society that helps us flourish
What would a society organised around Spinoza’s highest good look like? Education, medicine and technology emerge as practical conditions for a better life. Michah and Clare discuss how these familiar priorities serve his larger philosophical purpose, and why his ambition remains pragmatic: to help as many people as possible attain this good, as easily and reliably as possible.
§15 · Learning to value goodness
The discussion of education opens onto a question about how we bring up children. Do rewards and punishments help them learn to live well, or obscure the joy that good actions can bring in themselves? Michah and Clare consider Spinoza’s challenge to conventional moral education alongside Maimonides’ account of using rewards to lead children towards valuing study for its own sake.
§16 · Healing the intellect
Before undertaking this programme of reform, Spinoza says we must learn to understand things without error. Michah and Clare explore why philosophy needs a method for distinguishing truth from falsehood, and what it means to direct the sciences towards human perfection. His rejection of knowledge that does not advance this goal raises a further question about the value of inquiry and its place in a university.
§17 · Living while we learn
We cannot put life on hold while we work towards understanding. Spinoza introduces practical rules to guide us along the way, beginning with the need to speak according to the understanding of ordinary people. Michah and Clare consider the provisional character of these rules and why communicating truth requires attention to the experiences, emotions and beliefs of those we hope to reach.
§17 · How should we read Spinoza?
Spinoza’s first rule also invites us to think about his own writing. From the personal narrative of the Treatise to the geometrical form of the Ethics, he experiments with ways of leading readers towards unfamiliar ideas. Michah and Clare discuss the religious dangers surrounding his work and ask how far his strategy extends: does he always say what he believes? The episode closes with this question open, ahead of the remaining rules on pleasure and money.
Read alongside us
The edition used in the podcast
A Spinoza Reader
The Ethics and Other Works · Edited and translated by Edwin Curley
The hosts read from this Princeton University Press anthology. It includes the Ethics and selections from Spinoza’s other writings. Follow the paragraph numbers listed with each episode; page numbers vary between editions.
Exclusive podcast offer: buy A Spinoza Reader, edited by Edwin Curley, direct from Princeton University Press and use code SPINOZA (all caps) for 40% off.
